Clap Your Mars Say Yeah!
Tonight i finally got to see the Veronica Mars season 2 finale Not Pictured again. So here is my review.
What I loved in this episode
i) Keith giving Veronica a pep talk after the Aaron Echolls acquittal-but then being unable to to stay away from the newspaper himself.
ii) the camera pulling back to reveal Vinny in a cell. "I'm the 60 by the way."
iii) the dream sequence. No, the dream sequence! Veronica's visit of what her life would have been like if Lily hadn't been killed. Veronica: just as witty, but more superficial. And not nearly as good a student, sinced she's going to San Diego State. And gullible. Wallace: "Oh... you're one of those." Seeing Amanda Seyfreid as Lily again. Probably for the last time, but you never know.
iv) Woody's alias at the hunting lodge: "Mr. Underhill." That's the alias Frodo assumes when he leaves the Shire at the beginning of the Fellowship of the Rings.
v) seeing Wallace's mom again. Whatever happened to her? I liked her
vi) "Close your eyes and think of England." Might be funniest line ever on V-mars and that's saying a lot.
vii) Veronica getting cheered at graduation. "Don't keep all your passwords under your stapler."
viii) "up... chuck?" If they don't find a way to fit Dick Casablancas into next season I'm going to be very pissed.
ix) Jackie's mom. Gotta love the cliche tough brooklyn mom.
x) Logan and Aaron's heartcolding reunion.
xi) Woody watching the Dukes of Hazzard. Then throwing the staghead at Keith. Keith showing he's just as handy with the taser as Veronica-maybe more so.
xii) Veronica seeing the fatal words "Not Pictured" and her moment of dark epiphany. The use of the chain of transmission of venereal disease as a major clue. Has that been done before?
xiii) "it's liquid... it's courage... it's liquid courage"
xiv) Corky's moment of glory: "that sleazoid's going to fry... bzzzty" Another character who needs to end up at "Hearst College."
xv) Mac comforting Beaver.
xvi) Veronica and Aaron riding in the elevator together. Veronica not losing it, or even reacting, to Aaron's taunting... just looking at him in the eye.
xvii) Kristin Bell's acting during the rooftop sequence. She did a good job with a scene that was filled with both exposition and potential histrionics.
xviii) Logan stopping Veronica from shooting Beaver. "You are not a killer, Veronica."
"My name is Cassidy." Logan using his real name for the first time. Being unable to answer why not. The song that played over that moment.
xix) Mac's look of utter devestation.
xx) "Any more freedoming tonight and i'm going to need a wheelchair." You know, I don't actually hate Kendell Casablancas. She's kind of an epic character. Aaron's last moment on earth, spent watching a younger version of himself. A narccisist to his last. "CW?" "It's a done deal."
xxi) the little girl they found to play Veronica. Absolutely perfect.
xxii) Kendell ending up with $8mm and change.
xxiii) Veronica's description of how Logan is taking his father's death. "I didn't know you could come out during the day." Keith being tempted by what Kendell had in the briefcast.
xxiv) the strange closing shot... Veronica getting stood up by her dad. What does that portend?
One not-so-great thing
i) Glaring plothole; if Keith changed his plans wouldn't he have tried to call Veronica and let her know? Maybe his cel phone ran out of juice. Maybe it's part of next season's mystery. Maybe it's just a reminder that, in the end, it's a TV show written in a tremendous hurry and not everything is going to make 100% sense.
All in all, that held up to the standard set by season 2. a season that, if not quite matching up to the emotional intensity of season 1, more than matched it in plot complexity and glorious characterization.
Some more random thoughts
Last season Veronica was rescued by her father. This season it was Logan. I kind of like the fact that Veronica is not a butt-kicker. Yes, it means she's always depending on men to bail her out in the end.
Given the "CW? It's a done deal" exchange and the setting up of season 3 (which they didn't do last season) it seems like Rob Thomas is pretty confident they're coming back. Either that or he's one cocky motherfucker. We'll find out for sure on Thursday.
Comments
It was such a rockin' episode. Who'da thunk that Beav was the one that raped her.
I did however guess that he was the bad guy, with the previews they showed for this ep. What else would make Mac cry so badly, by herself?
Re: your plot hole - Veronica didn't have a signal for her phone in the airport. They showed a close up on it. "No service" or something. So it's very possible Keith did call her. But since she'd already checked in, and didn't have service, she wouldn't know.
I like how she's not super butt-kicker girl, but I do wish she didn't have to be rescued by a dude every time. Maybe that's my closet feminism peeking out...
With regard to the dream sequence, I thought it was interesting how everything was as it would've been without Lilly's murder EXCEPT that she was dating Logan, and Duncan was the dork hangin' with Dick.
i loved all the things you mentioned. and likewise hated the plot holes that seemed completely fixable with a phone call.
also, (just to be kinda nit-picky, cause i really loved it) - why does veronica freak-the-frak out about talking to mac when she realizes it's beaver who is the bad guy.
firstly, mac and beaver were together lots of times - so i don't think he was plotting mischieviousness (well, not that kind, anyways - lol)
secondly, we never saw any inkling that beaver was going to turn violent or planned to killing anyone at the party.
thirdly, it was never explained why, since he didn't seem to be up to some masterminding plot of evil, he had a gun in his bookbag.
fourth, why would someone as smart as veronica
A. text message something like "Beaver is a killer." to mac's cellphone when she knows they are together.
B. say "meet me on the roof." when she knows that not only is Beaver a killer, but even creepy Haaron meets her in the elevator and gives ME the heebies. (how about "meet me in the very crowded lounge area and bring a strong man that is not Beaver)
C. not have avoided this whole confrontation by . . . (well, in an ideal universe, you could go to the police, but if i had to choose between Lamb and the rooftop of terror, i might make the same choice v did)
fifth, i didin't buy Beaver's switch from abused crazy to psycho crazy.
final thought, i will say that keith really probably wouldn't have called veronica, because for all he knows, she is just graduated and having a super-fun time and doesn't care that he was on the plane or not. although, the gap in time of her falling asleep and him coming home is a huge hole because he should have heard about the crash (or seen it in the sky - cause, man it was huge) and THEN thought maybe he should call or decide he might should wake her ass up when he came home.)
otherwise.
is it a pony?!
upchuck the boogie. (i love dick too - he needs to be in next season)
see, i wasn't kidding when i said i was dying to lengthily discuss (.e. spam your comments)! :)
how about we just overlook all the glaring typos in that previous comment. k? great!